The Problem Is Real — and Urgent
Source: 2025 Social Security Trustees Report. After trust fund depletion, ongoing payroll taxes can pay ~77% of scheduled benefits — benefits don't go to zero, but the cut is automatic and significant.
The Prosperity Trust: How It Works
Not a replacement. An upgrade. We keep Social Security's safety net and add real ownership on top — modeled on the federal Thrift Savings Plan that already manages over $1 trillion for government employees.
Keep the 12.4% Payroll Contribution — Remove the Cap
No tax increase on rate. But the current $176,100 earnings cap is eliminated. Every dollar you earn is covered. The rate stays the same — it just applies to all income. This generates massive additional revenue for the transition and safety net.
6% Goes to Your Personal Account
Deposited into a Prosperity Trust Account — a TSP-style account you own outright. Invested in low-cost index funds with expense ratios under 0.05%. You choose your risk level; a sensible default is set automatically. No cap means high earners build proportionally larger accounts — wealth they keep and pass to heirs.
6.4% Funds the Safety Net (During Transition)
Continues to fund: a guaranteed base retirement benefit, disability insurance (SSDI), supplementary survivor insurance for young workers, and the transition for current retirees. No one currently receiving benefits loses a penny.
Current Retirees: Zero Change
If you're retired or within 10 years of retirement, your benefits remain exactly as they are. This transition is phased in over 20 years for workers under 50.
Your Account, Your Legacy
Borrow against your balance once every 5 years. At retirement, withdrawals follow structured tiers designed to make your money last — and grow:
- Ages 60–70: 4% per year
- Ages 70–80: 5% per year
- Ages 80–90: 7% per year
- Ages 90+: 10% per year
If your balance exceeds 25x the minimum benefit floor (~$1M+), the excess above that threshold can be withdrawn freely — you've built enough that you literally can't run out.
When you pass away, the full remaining balance goes to your heirs tax-free. This IS your survivor benefit — real inheritable wealth, not a reduced government check.
A Guaranteed Floor
If markets underperform and your account falls short, the government guarantees a minimum benefit floor — no American retires with nothing, regardless of market conditions.
No Retirement Age — It's Your Money
There's no arbitrary cutoff. Your account grows as long as you contribute. Want to retire at 55 with a large balance? Your choice. Want to keep building until 75? The account has no end date. Retirement is a personal decision, not a government mandate.
What This Means in Real Dollars
Projections for a worker contributing 6% of income over a 40-year career. All figures in today's dollars (inflation-adjusted). Assumes low-cost diversified index fund.
| Scenario | Median Earner ($45,000/yr) |
Average Earner ($67,000/yr) |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Contribution (6%) | $2,700 | $4,020 |
| Account at 65 — Conservative (4% real return) | $257,000 | $382,000 |
| Account at 65 — Moderate (5% real return) | $326,000 | $486,000 |
| Account at 65 — Historical Avg. (7% real return) | $539,000 | $803,000 |
| Annual Income (4% withdrawal + base benefit) | $21,000 – $33,500 | $29,000 – $46,000 |
| Current Social Security benefit | ~$18,000 | ~$23,700 |
| Inheritable wealth left to family | $257k – $539k | $382k – $803k |
Assumptions & methodology: 40-year contribution period, constant real income, 4% annual withdrawal rate (Trinity Study). "Base benefit" assumes a reduced Social Security floor of ~$8,000–$14,000/year funded by the remaining 6.4%. Conservative scenario uses 4% real return (typical for a bond-heavy portfolio); moderate uses 5% (balanced 60/40); historical uses 7% (S&P 500 long-run average, per Macrotrends). Based on historical S&P 500 returns. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Actual outcomes depend on market conditions, contribution consistency, and fees. TSP-style expense ratios assumed (~0.04%).
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Current Social Security | The Prosperity Trust |
|---|---|---|
| Who owns the money | Government | You |
| Total contribution rate | 12.4% (capped at $176K) | 12.4% → ~8.5% long-term (no cap) |
| Retirement income (avg. earner) | ~$23,700/yr | $29,000 – $46,000/yr |
| Disability coverage | Yes | Yes (funded by safety net) |
| Survivor benefits | Reduced monthly check, ends at death | Full account balance to heirs, tax-free |
| Guaranteed minimum benefit | Yes | Yes (base benefit floor) |
| Can borrow from your account | No | Yes (once per 5 years) |
| Inheritable by your family | No — benefits die with you | Full balance to heirs, tax-free |
| Insolvency risk | 23% cut projected by 2033 | Diversified: market + guaranteed floor |
| Investment model | Government bonds only (~2% real) | TSP-style index funds (~5–7% real) |
Why This Matters — For Everyone
Closing the Racial Wealth Gap
Black and Hispanic workers pay into Social Security their entire lives but, due to lower average life expectancy, collect benefits for fewer years. Worse — when they die, their family inherits nothing. The Prosperity Trust turns a lifetime of contributions into inheritable wealth that builds across generations.
Financial Independence for Women
Under current Social Security, a stay-at-home spouse's benefit depends on their partner's work record. A Prosperity Trust Account belongs to each individual — with spousal contribution options that build independent financial security.
Ending the Two-Tier System
Members of Congress and federal employees already build wealth through the Thrift Savings Plan. The Prosperity Trust simply extends that same system to every working American. If it's good enough for Congress, it's good enough for the rest of us.
Proven Around the World
Australia's Superannuation system (12% contribution, $4.3 trillion in assets) dramatically increased retirement security. Sweden runs personal accounts alongside its public pension. Singapore's CPF ranks among the world's best. This isn't theory — it's tested reality.
The Economic Case
Solves Insolvency
The transition makes Social Security's $25.1 trillion unfunded obligation explicit and funds it — rather than kicking the can to 2033.
Boosts National Savings
Trillions in new investment capital flowing into the economy. More savings means more jobs, higher wages, and stronger growth.
Reduces Future Liability
As personal accounts mature, the government's retirement obligation shrinks — freeing resources for healthcare, infrastructure, and education.
Broadens Ownership
Tens of millions of Americans who've never owned a stock become investors. Ownership creates civic engagement, stability, and long-term thinking.
The Transition: A 30-Year Roadmap
Honest reform takes time. Here's the phased plan — including how the rate drops once legacy obligations are met.
Launch & Opt-In
- Workers under 50 begin contributing 6% to personal Prosperity Trust Accounts
- Remaining 6.4% continues funding current retirees, disability, and survivors
- Workers over 50 may opt in voluntarily
- Current retirees see zero changes to their benefits
Close the Gap: Cap Removal + The Patriot Provision
Two mechanisms dramatically accelerate the transition:
- Remove the earnings cap. Currently, only the first $176,100 of income is taxed. Removing the cap means all earnings are covered. High earners contribute more to the safety net — but they also build proportionally larger personal accounts. The wealthy contribute more and build more. Everyone gives, everyone gains. Estimated additional revenue: $80–120 billion/year.
- The Patriot Provision. High-income retirees ($250K+ income or $2M+ net worth) can voluntarily waive SS benefits in exchange for a Transition Tax Credit worth 75% of their annual benefit. Government nets 25% savings per participant. Estimated savings: $50–70 billion/year.
Combined: $130–190 billion/year — closing 52–76% of the transition gap before bonds or general revenue are needed.
Transition Matures
- Dedicated transition bonds and general revenue fund the remaining gap (making the implicit $25.1T debt explicit — the debt already exists)
- As legacy retirees pass and new retirees draw from personal accounts, the safety-net portion shrinks naturally
- Progressive government matching for low-income accounts begins from year 1
The Rate Drops
Once all retirees are drawing from personal accounts and legacy obligations are met, the safety-net fund only needs to cover:
| Disability insurance (SSDI) | ~1.7% |
| Supplementary survivor insurance | ~0.2% |
| Minimum benefit guarantee | ~0.3–0.5% |
| Progressive matching for low-income workers | ~0.2% |
| Administration | ~0.1% |
| Total safety net | ~2.5% |
| Personal accounts | 6% |
| New total rate | ~8.5% |
That's a 3.9 percentage point cut from today's 12.4% — about $2,600/year back for the average earner. Real tax relief, earned through a real transition rather than wishful math.
Why is survivor coverage so low? Because the account itself IS the survivor benefit. When you die, your full balance passes tax-free to your family — real inheritable wealth, not a reduced government check. The small supplementary fund covers only edge cases where young workers pass away before building significant balances.
Tough Questions — Answered Honestly
No serious proposal ducks the hard questions. Here are the strongest objections and our direct responses.
"What about a stock market crash right before retirement?"
This is a real risk, and we take it seriously. Three safeguards address it:
- Lifecycle investing. Like the TSP's Lifecycle (L) Funds, the default investment automatically shifts from stocks to bonds as you approach retirement. A 60-year-old's portfolio looks very different from a 25-year-old's.
- The guaranteed base benefit. The 6.4% that stays in the traditional system provides a floor — you still receive a base Social Security check regardless of market conditions.
- Minimum benefit guarantee. If your combined income (personal account + base benefit) falls below a minimum threshold, the government tops it up.
No system eliminates all risk. The current system faces its own risk — a guaranteed 23% benefit cut by 2033 if nothing changes. The Prosperity Trust diversifies risk across both markets and government guarantees.
"Who pays for current retirees during the transition?"
This is the hardest question, and we won't pretend it's easy. The 6.4% that stays in the traditional system continues to fund current benefits. During the transition (20–30 years), there will be a gap. We close it through five mechanisms:
- Remove the earnings cap. Currently only the first $176,100 is taxed. Removing the cap generates an estimated $80–120 billion/year in new revenue — and high earners also build proportionally larger personal accounts, so it's a genuine win-win.
- The Patriot Provision: Wealthy retirees who don't need SS can voluntarily waive benefits in exchange for a 75% Transition Tax Credit — saving an additional $50–70B/year.
- Dedicated transition bonds: Making the implicit $25.1 trillion debt explicit. The debt already exists — we're acknowledging it honestly rather than pretending it away.
- Gradual phase-in: Only workers under 50 in year one, expanding slowly.
- Natural attrition: As legacy retirees pass and new retirees draw from personal accounts, the gap closes itself over time.
Combined, the cap removal and Patriot Provision alone close an estimated 52–76% of the annual transition gap. Chile managed its transition over 25 years. Australia phased in over 33 years. This is a generational project, not an overnight switch. The alternative — doing nothing — leads to automatic benefit cuts in 2033.
"What about disability and survivor benefits?"
Disability: Fully preserved. The safety-net fund continues to provide disability insurance (SSDI) for workers who can't work. This is funded by the safety-net portion of the payroll contribution.
Survivors: Actually better under the Prosperity Trust. Under current Social Security, when you die, your family gets a reduced monthly check that eventually ends — and the contributions you paid over your lifetime vanish. Under the Prosperity Trust, your family inherits the full account balance, tax-free. A worker who dies at 55 with $400,000 in their account passes real, permanent wealth to their family — not a temporary government check.
For edge cases where a young worker dies before building significant savings, a small supplementary survivor insurance fund covers the gap. But for the vast majority of families, the inheritable account IS the survivor benefit — and it's far more valuable.
"What if people make terrible investment decisions?"
They won't have to make decisions at all — unless they want to. The default is a TSP-style Lifecycle Fund that automatically adjusts based on your age. Workers who want more control can choose from a small menu of pre-approved, low-cost index funds (just like the TSP's five fund options). There are no individual stock picks, no day trading, no predatory advisors.
The TSP has proven this works for 6+ million federal employees. The average participant doesn't need a finance degree.
"Isn't this just privatization by another name?"
No. Privatization would mean handing Social Security to Wall Street. This proposal uses government-administered accounts — the same infrastructure that runs the Thrift Savings Plan, with expense ratios of 0.04% (compared to ~0.42% for the average mutual fund). No Wall Street middlemen. No profit motive. Just low-cost index funds managed at government scale.
This is also not a replacement — it's a supplement. The guaranteed base benefit, disability insurance, and survivor benefits continue through the traditional system.
"What about low-income workers who can't afford to save?"
Two protections:
- Progressive matching. The government contributes additional funds to the accounts of workers earning below the median income — making this system more redistributive than current Social Security, not less.
- Guaranteed minimum benefit. Regardless of account performance, no retiree's combined income falls below a set floor.
Current Social Security is less progressive than it appears — lower-income workers have shorter average life expectancies and collect benefits for fewer years. They also leave zero inheritable wealth. Personal accounts with progressive matching address both problems.
The Proof Already Exists
The Thrift Savings Plan (USA)
$1+ trillion in assets. 6 million+ participants. Expense ratios of 0.04%. The TSP proves the federal government can run a massive, low-cost personal account system. tsp.gov
Australia's Superannuation
AU$4.3 trillion in assets. 12% employer contribution (phased in from 3% over 33 years). Projected to become the world's 2nd-largest pension system by 2031. Broad bipartisan support. Source
Sweden's Premium Pension
2.5% of payroll goes to personal accounts alongside the public pension. Default fund option for those who don't want to choose. A balanced "supplement, not replacement" model.
A note on Chile: Chile pioneered personal retirement accounts in 1981 with mixed results — strong early returns but high fees and inadequate benefits for many workers. The Prosperity Trust learns from Chile's mistakes by using government-administered accounts (not private fund managers), guaranteeing a minimum benefit floor, and maintaining disability/survivor coverage. SSA analysis of Chile's system
The Road to a Bill
Real reform follows a real process. Here's the proven path from citizen proposal to federal law — and where we are right now.
Build the Foundation
- Gather public interest and feedback through this site
- Build an email list of supporters across all 50 states
- Develop detailed policy papers with independent economic modeling
- Your voice matters most at this stage — early supporters shape the proposal
Coalition Building
- Partner with allied organizations — retiree groups, financial planning associations, worker advocacy organizations, and bipartisan think tanks
- Recruit economists, policy experts, and former government officials to validate and refine the proposal
- Commission independent actuarial analysis
- Build "grasstops" support — community leaders with relationships to legislators
Find Congressional Sponsors
- Present polished draft legislation to sympathetic members of Congress
- Target members on the House Ways and Means Committee and Senate Finance Committee — the two committees with jurisdiction over Social Security
- Seek bipartisan co-sponsors — critical because Social Security reform cannot pass through budget reconciliation and needs 60 Senate votes to overcome a filibuster
Committee Process
- Bill referred to House Ways and Means (Subcommittee on Social Security) and Senate Finance (Subcommittee on Social Security, Pensions, and Family Policy)
- Committee hearings with expert testimony, Congressional Budget Office scoring, and markup sessions
- If a committee blocks the bill, a discharge petition (218 House signatures) can force a floor vote — exactly how the Social Security Fairness Act advanced in 2024
Floor Votes
- House: simple majority (218 votes)
- Senate: 60-vote cloture threshold to overcome filibuster, then simple majority for passage
- Conference committee reconciles any differences between House and Senate versions
Signed Into Law
- President signs or vetoes within 10 days
- Congress can override a veto with a two-thirds vote in both chambers
Most bills take 5–10 years from grassroots movement to law. The Social Security Fairness Act was reintroduced across multiple Congresses before passing in 2024 with bipartisan support (327–75 in the House, 76–20 in the Senate). MADD went from a single grieving mother in 1980 to federal legislation in 1984. Real reform takes persistence — and it starts with people like you.
Help Shape This Proposal
This isn't a finished bill — it's a starting point. Your feedback, questions, and ideas will directly shape the legislation we bring to Congress.
Ready to Support Real Retirement Reform?
Sign up for updates, the one-page proposal PDF, and action alerts when this reaches your state's representatives.